53 W College Avenue Step into timeless elegance at 53 West College Avenue, a beautifully preserved home in the heart of Westerville's historic district. Nestled on tree-lined College Avenue, this 5 bed, 3.5 bath residence blends historic charm with modern updates and inviting spaces inside and out. Showcasing original hardwood floors, vintage moldings, and architectural details, the home reflects Westerville's rich heritage. A welcoming screened-in porch and spacious interior create the perfect setting for both everyday living and entertaining. Outdoor living is a true highlight with multiple places to relax or host gatherings: a new patio, hot tub, and private courtyard with updated fencing. A versatile carriage house/outbuilding offers endless possibilities as an art studio, exercise room, or workshop. Just steps from Uptown Westerville, you'll enjoy easy access to local favorites like Java Central, Northstar Café, the Farmers Market, shops, parks, and community events, while being minutes from Otterbein University. Recent updates include: new hot tub and patio, new side patio and decking, new dishwasher, garbage disposal, updated lower-level shower, new vanities, sinks and flooring, new gutters, courtyard fencing, new front bedroom windows, and fresh paint. Don't miss this rare opportunity to own a piece of Westerville's legacy—schedule your private showing today!